Gender Dysphoria and the Self-Concept: Navigating the Challenges of Identity

Understanding how gender dysphoria can affect self-image, self-esteem and our relationship with ourselves.

By Marianne Oakes, Founder of Evolve Online Counselling

Who are we, and how do we come to understand ourselves?

It's a question that sits at the heart of much of the counselling work I do.

Our sense of self develops throughout our lives, shaped by our experiences, relationships, beliefs and the way other people respond to us. Over time, we begin to form an understanding of who we are, how we fit into the world and how we believe others see us.

In counselling, we often refer to this as our self-concept.

For some transgender and non-binary people, the relationship between their internal sense of identity and the expectations placed upon them by society can become complicated, particularly when they are experiencing gender dysphoria.

As a transgender woman and therapeutic counsellor, I understand how difficult it can be when the person you know yourself to be doesn't seem to match the person the world expects you to be.

In this article, I want to explore how gender dysphoria can influence our self-concept, why self-acceptance can sometimes feel so difficult and how counselling may help us develop a more compassionate relationship with ourselves.

What is the self-concept?

The self-concept is the collection of beliefs, perceptions and feelings we hold about ourselves.

It includes how we see our personality, abilities, relationships, values, appearance and identity.

In person-centred counselling, Carl Rogers explored the importance of the self-concept and the relationship between how we see ourselves and the person we would ideally like to be.

When these aspects of ourselves feel relatively consistent, we may experience a greater sense of psychological wellbeing.

However, when there is a significant difference between how we experience ourselves and how we believe we are expected to be, we may experience what Rogers described as incongruence.

This can contribute to anxiety, uncertainty and difficulties with self-acceptance.

For transgender people, experiences of incongruence may arise when their gender identity is not recognised or when they feel pressured to live according to expectations that don't reflect who they are.

Importantly, being transgender is not itself a psychological problem or evidence of an unhealthy self-concept.

The difficulties often arise from distress, conflicting expectations, discrimination or the challenges of living in an environment where someone feels unable to express their identity.

Understanding gender dysphoria

Gender dysphoria describes the distress or discomfort that some people experience when there is a difference between their gender identity and aspects of their body, social role or how other people perceive them.

For some individuals, this distress may be connected to physical characteristics.

For others, it may involve being referred to by an incorrect name or pronouns, feeling misunderstood or being expected to conform to a gender role that doesn't reflect their identity.

Not every transgender person experiences gender dysphoria, and those who do may experience it differently throughout their lives.

Some people also experience gender euphoria, the positive feelings that can arise when their identity is recognised and they feel comfortable expressing themselves.

Understanding these experiences can be an important part of developing a more positive relationship with ourselves.

How can gender dysphoria affect the self-concept?

Our self-concept is influenced not only by how we see ourselves but also by the messages we receive from other people.

From childhood, we learn what society expects from us.

We are often encouraged to behave, dress and express ourselves in ways associated with the gender we were assigned at birth.

For someone whose gender identity differs from those expectations, this can create considerable emotional conflict.

They may know how they feel internally but struggle to reconcile those feelings with the expectations of family, friends, colleagues or society.

Over time, this can contribute to self-doubt, low confidence or a sense of being disconnected from themselves.

Some people begin to question whether their feelings are valid.

Others may become so accustomed to meeting other people's expectations that they struggle to recognise their own needs.

As a counsellor, I believe it's important to recognise that these difficulties don't mean someone's identity is confused or invalid.

Sometimes, the greatest challenge is not understanding who we are, but finding the freedom to be ourselves.

The influence of conditions of worth

One of the concepts I find particularly relevant to gender identity is Carl Rogers' idea of conditions of worth.

Conditions of worth develop when we begin to believe that we must behave or present ourselves in particular ways to receive love, approval or acceptance.

For example, someone may grow up believing that they will only be accepted if they conform to traditional expectations of masculinity or femininity.

They may learn to hide certain feelings, interests or aspects of their identity because they fear disappointing others.

Over time, these expectations can become deeply internalised.

A transgender person may find themselves thinking:

  • Will my family still love me if I tell them who I am?

  • Will people respect me if I express my gender differently?

  • Am I allowed to feel comfortable with my identity?

  • What happens if I don't meet other people's expectations?

These questions can have a significant impact on self-esteem and emotional wellbeing.

When acceptance feels conditional, it can become difficult to offer ourselves the same understanding and compassion that we would readily offer someone else.

Internal conflict and self-doubt

For some transgender people, gender dysphoria can be accompanied by years of internal conflict.

They may experience a strong sense of their gender identity while simultaneously feeling frightened about what acknowledging it might mean.

There may be concerns about relationships, employment, family acceptance or personal safety.

Some people try to ignore or suppress their feelings because they believe doing so will make life easier.

Others may experience shame or guilt, particularly if they have grown up surrounded by negative messages about transgender identities.

These experiences can affect confidence and contribute to anxiety, low mood or feelings of isolation.

It is important to remember that these emotional difficulties are not inevitable consequences of being transgender.

They are often influenced by the circumstances in which someone is trying to understand and express their identity.

The importance of self-acceptance

Self-acceptance can be an important part of developing a healthier self-concept.

However, self-acceptance isn't always straightforward.

For someone who has spent years questioning themselves or trying to meet other people's expectations, learning to recognise their own feelings as valid can take time.

It may involve exploring long-held beliefs, understanding the influence of past experiences and developing a more compassionate relationship with themselves.

Self-acceptance doesn't mean that every difficulty disappears.

It doesn't mean that someone must feel confident all the time or have all the answers about their future.

Instead, it means beginning to recognise that their feelings, identity and experiences deserve respect.

Sometimes, this process begins with relatively small steps.

Using a name that feels comfortable.

Allowing yourself to explore different ways of expressing your gender.

Talking openly with someone you trust.

Or simply acknowledging feelings that you may have spent years trying to ignore.

There is no single pathway towards self-acceptance, and everyone's experience will be different.

How society influences our sense of self

Our relationship with ourselves doesn't develop in isolation.

The attitudes and behaviours of people around us can have a profound influence on how we feel about our identity.

For transgender people, experiences of discrimination, rejection, misgendering or social exclusion can affect self-esteem and emotional wellbeing.

Even when someone has developed a strong understanding of their gender identity, repeatedly having that identity questioned or dismissed can be emotionally exhausting.

This is why supportive relationships and inclusive environments matter.

When people feel respected and accepted, they are often better able to develop confidence and a positive sense of self.

Creating an accepting society isn't about expecting everyone to have identical experiences or opinions.

It's about recognising that every person deserves dignity, compassion and the opportunity to live without unnecessary fear or discrimination.

How can person-centred counselling help?

As a person-centred counsellor, my approach is grounded in the belief that people have the capacity to develop greater self-understanding when they are offered the right therapeutic environment.

Carl Rogers identified three important qualities within the therapeutic relationship: empathy, congruence and unconditional positive regard.

These principles remain central to my work.

Empathy means making a genuine effort to understand your experiences from your perspective.

Congruence means offering an authentic and honest therapeutic relationship.

Unconditional positive regard means accepting and respecting you as a person without placing conditions on your worth.

For someone experiencing gender dysphoria or struggling with their self-concept, these qualities can provide an opportunity to explore feelings that may previously have been difficult to express.

Counselling can help you reflect on the expectations you've experienced, recognise the influence of other people's attitudes and develop a clearer understanding of your own needs.

My role isn't to determine your gender identity or tell you what decisions to make.

Instead, I offer a safe, confidential and affirming space where you can explore your experiences without judgement or pressure.

The aim is to support your emotional wellbeing and help you develop a relationship with yourself that feels more accepting and authentic.

Rebuilding confidence and a positive self-image

Developing a positive self-concept doesn't mean becoming someone different.

Sometimes, it means recognising the parts of ourselves that have been overlooked, criticised or hidden.

For transgender people, this may involve challenging negative beliefs about their identity, recognising personal strengths and developing greater confidence in expressing themselves.

It may also involve exploring relationships, establishing boundaries and finding supportive people who respect their individuality.

These changes don't necessarily happen quickly.

There may be setbacks, difficult emotions or periods of uncertainty.

But with understanding, support and self-compassion, it is possible to develop a stronger and more accepting sense of self.

You deserve to be yourself

Our self-concept shapes how we experience ourselves and the world around us.

When we feel that our identity is constantly being questioned or that we must meet other people's expectations to be accepted, it can become difficult to recognise our own worth.

But our value as individuals isn't determined by how closely we conform to society's expectations.

As a transgender woman, I understand the importance of being able to recognise yourself and feel comfortable with who you are.

And as a counsellor, I believe that everyone deserves the opportunity to explore their identity in an environment built on empathy, respect and understanding.

You don't have to become the person other people expect you to be in order to deserve acceptance.

At Evolve Online Counselling, I offer specialist online gender-affirming counselling for transgender, non-binary and gender-questioning individuals across the UK.

Whether you're experiencing gender dysphoria, struggling with self-esteem or exploring your relationship with yourself, counselling can offer a supportive space to talk openly and develop greater self-understanding.

Because understanding who we are is not about fitting into someone else's expectations. It's about discovering how to live comfortably and authentically as ourselves.

Previous
Previous

Embracing Transgender Rights: A Pathway to Equality and Inclusion

Next
Next

The History of Transgender People: From Ancient Civilisations to Today