Sex testing in women's sport: The potential impact on female athletes

After the recent news that female athletes could be subject to sex testing, I feel compelled to say something.

In my view, no man is ever going to have to prove his sex. Not one. Yet every female athlete now seems at risk of disqualification based on a single test—one that many critics have questioned as flawed and unreliable, much like previous testosterone limits and sex verification rules used by organisations such as the International Olympic Committee and World Athletics.

From where I stand, this doesn’t really appear to be about trans women. If officials truly wanted to, they already have ways to investigate an athlete’s history. And honestly, if someone believes the idea that “you can always tell,” then why would there be a need to test every single woman?

The Human Cost for Women and Girls

Imagine being a female athlete right now. Years of dedication—early mornings, missed social moments, relentless training—only to be told you’ve failed a test that doesn’t fully account for the natural diversity of women’s bodies. Not because of cheating, but because your biology doesn’t fit neatly into a predefined box.

Meanwhile, it seems unlikely that boys are facing the same scrutiny. They can pursue their ambitions without questioning whether they are “male enough” to compete.

I worry about what this could mean for girls. Will some parents hesitate before encouraging their daughters into sport? What happens when young people begin to internalise the idea that their bodies might be “wrong” or “not enough”?

As a trans woman, I know how damaging that message can be. And I can’t help but feel concerned at the thought of more young people—cis or trans—growing up with that same sense of shame.

A Slippery Slope Beyond Sport

In my opinion, policies like this rarely stay confined to one area. When we begin questioning and policing women’s bodies in elite sport, it can influence how bodies are viewed more broadly in society.

We’ve seen similar patterns before, and they tend to raise more questions than they answer.

There has already been significant controversy around athletes like Caster Semenya, whose career was deeply affected by regulations tied to naturally high testosterone levels, including rulings from the Court of Arbitration for Sport. Situations like this, to me, highlight just how complex and potentially unfair these approaches can become.

Is This Really Protecting Women’s Sport?

From my perspective, this isn’t about protecting women’s sport—it risks undermining it.

It introduces uncertainty, fear, and exclusion into spaces that should be about opportunity, achievement, and belonging.

And for once, I’m not softening my words: to me, this feels like a deeply harmful decision for women.

About the Author

Marianne Oakes is a trans woman and qualified therapeutic counsellor who works exclusively with transgender, non-binary, and gender-diverse clients. She is a registered member of the British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy (BACP) and BAGIS, providing affirming, specialist support across the UK.

Previous
Previous

Thriving through challenge: Finding hope and resilience as a transgender person

Next
Next

Marianne, she's my dad: Growing up with a transgender parent