Gender Recognition Reform: The Political Debate and Its Impact on Transgender Mental Health

Why the Gender Recognition Reform Bill affected me personally, and how we can protect our emotional wellbeing during difficult times.

By Marianne Oakes, Founder of Evolve Online Counselling

The Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill became one of the most significant political issues affecting transgender and non-binary people in the UK.

But behind the political arguments, newspaper headlines and social media debates, there is something that can easily become forgotten.

The emotional wellbeing of transgender and gender-diverse people.

As a transgender woman and therapeutic counsellor, I have seen the distress that political uncertainty and public hostility can cause.

I hear about it in the therapy room, through the experiences of people who are trying to live their lives while feeling that their identities, dignity and rights are constantly being debated.

And I would be lying if I said that I haven't been affected personally.

When hope turned into disappointment

When the Scottish Parliament passed the Gender Recognition Reform Bill in December 2022, I was genuinely pleased.

In my mind, it felt like an early Christmas present.

Perhaps 2023 would be a year of positive change. Perhaps we were moving towards a society where transgender people could experience greater dignity and recognition.

But how wrong could I be?

On 16 January 2023, the UK Government announced its decision to use Section 35 of the Scotland Act 1998 to prevent the Bill from proceeding to Royal Assent.

The Government argued that the proposed changes could have adverse effects on the operation of equality law across Great Britain. Supporters of the Bill viewed the intervention as an unnecessary barrier to simplifying legal gender recognition.

For many transgender people, myself included, the announcement was deeply disappointing.

It wasn't simply about legislation.

It was about what that decision represented to people who had hoped that their lives might become a little easier.

The emotional impact of political uncertainty

As a counsellor, I regularly support transgender and non-binary people who are navigating anxiety, discrimination, uncertainty and the challenges of living in a society where their identities are frequently discussed in public.

The political climate can become another emotional burden.

When your rights and identity are continually debated, it can become difficult to switch off.

There is always another headline.

Another social media argument.

Another politician expressing an opinion about people they may never have met.

And behind all of this are ordinary people trying to get on with their lives.

People with families, jobs, relationships, hopes and ambitions.

People who want the same things that most of us want: to feel safe, accepted and respected.

For some, the constant public discussion can contribute to anxiety, exhaustion and feelings of helplessness.

As a counsellor, I understand how important it is to acknowledge those feelings rather than dismiss them.

But I also recognise that we need ways to protect our emotional wellbeing.

How do I look after my own mental health?

As a professional counsellor, I have a responsibility to look after my emotional wellbeing.

If I cannot remain emotionally grounded, it becomes much harder to offer the support my clients need.

One of the questions I am asked most frequently is:

"How do you do it?"

How do I continue supporting other transgender people while also being affected by the same political and social climate?

The answer is perhaps simpler than people might expect.

I remind myself of my real life.

I go out and speak to my friends and neighbours.

And I am reminded that most of the people I encounter don't define me by the fact that I am a transgender woman.

They treat me according to the relationship we have and the impact I have on their lives.

To the best of my ability, I try to be a good friend and neighbour.

I'm not perfect, but I try.

And in return, I experience the ordinary kindness, friendship and acceptance that are part of everyday life.

Those experiences matter enormously to me.

They remind me that the world I encounter personally is often very different from the one presented through political arguments and social media.

The importance of family and relationships

I also have my family.

Some people might assume that because I'm a transgender woman, my family simply had to accept me.

But family relationships don't work like that.

Maintaining strong relationships takes effort from everyone involved.

Families grow, develop and change over time.

People change.

Circumstances change.

And relationships need to evolve alongside those changes.

Keeping my family relationships strong has been something we've all had to work at.

That isn't unique to being transgender.

It's part of family life.

We all have to learn how to understand one another, communicate and maintain the connections that matter to us.

For me, those relationships are an important source of emotional stability.

They remind me that I am not simply a transgender woman caught up in a political debate.

I am a person with a family, friendships, responsibilities and a life that extends far beyond my gender identity.

The headlines are not my everyday life

I know that all of this can be easier said than done.

There are times when I need to remind myself that the political climate, social media and wider media are not the entirety of my real life.

The people shouting the loudest do not necessarily represent everyone around us.

And transgender people are not the fictional characters that are sometimes created through sensationalist headlines.

We are ordinary people doing ordinary things.

We go shopping.

We work.

We look after our families.

We laugh with friends.

We worry about bills, relationships and all the other things that make us human.

I have met people with quite conservative views who have nevertheless treated me with warmth and respect once they have got to know me.

That doesn't mean prejudice or discrimination isn't real.

It certainly doesn't mean that the political decisions affecting transgender people are unimportant.

But it reminds me that people are often more complicated, and sometimes more compassionate, than the arguments taking place around us might suggest.

Remembering that we are individuals

One of the most difficult aspects of public debate about transgender people is how easily individuals become reduced to stereotypes.

People discuss transgender identities as though we are all the same.

As though we share identical experiences, beliefs, personalities and ambitions.

But we don't.

We are as varied and individual as anyone else.

I sometimes remind myself that the politicians discussing transgender people do not know me personally.

They don't know my family.

They don't know my friendships.

They don't know the work I do or the contribution I try to make to the lives of others.

Their decisions can certainly affect my rights and the lives of people in my community.

That is something we cannot simply ignore.

But the way transgender people are portrayed in political debate does not define who I am.

I am not a stereotype. I am not a headline. I am an individual human being.

And so are the people I support through counselling.

How counselling can help during difficult times

Counselling cannot change legislation or remove every difficulty we experience in society.

But it can help us understand how those experiences are affecting us emotionally.

It can provide a space to talk about anger, disappointment, anxiety, fear and exhaustion.

It can also help us reconnect with our sense of identity and recognise that our worth is not determined by other people's opinions.

As a person-centred counsellor, I believe that each individual has their own unique experiences, values and understanding of themselves.

My role is not to tell someone how they should feel about the political climate.

Instead, I offer a safe and confidential space where they can explore those feelings without judgement.

For some people, this may involve recognising when news and social media are becoming overwhelming.

For others, it may mean exploring relationships, developing boundaries or finding ways to reconnect with supportive people.

And sometimes, it is simply about having somewhere to express the exhaustion of constantly feeling that you must defend your existence.

Counselling can help us become more confident in our identities and develop a stronger relationship with ourselves.

It can remind us that we are not defined by the debates taking place around us.

Finding strength in who we are

I know that many transgender and non-binary people are experiencing difficult emotions in response to the political climate.

And I would never suggest that we should simply ignore what is happening.

Our rights matter.

Our safety matters.

Our emotional wellbeing matters.

But so does remembering that our lives are about more than politics.

We have people who love us.

We have friendships to enjoy.

We have ambitions, achievements and futures worth looking forward to.

And we each have our own unique place in the world.

For me, maintaining that perspective is one of the ways I protect my own emotional wellbeing.

I remind myself that I am Marianne.

I am a transgender woman, but I am also a counsellor, a family member, a friend, a neighbour and an individual with my own strengths and imperfections.

My gender identity is an important part of who I am.

But it is not the entirety of who I am.

You are more than the debate surrounding you

If there is one thing I would like transgender and non-binary people to take away from this article, it is this:

You are not the person being portrayed in the headlines. You are your own unique version of a human being.

You deserve to feel confident in your identity.

You deserve relationships built on respect and understanding.

And you deserve the opportunity to live your life without constantly feeling that you must justify who you are.

The political climate may be difficult, and there may be times when the future feels uncertain.

But those difficulties do not diminish your worth.

As a counsellor, I believe that therapy can offer an opportunity to reconnect with ourselves, recognise our strengths and discover the potential that can sometimes become hidden beneath anxiety and fear.

At Evolve Online Counselling, I provide specialist online gender-affirming counselling for transgender, non-binary and gender-questioning individuals across the UK.

Whether you're struggling with political uncertainty, discrimination, anxiety, self-esteem or simply feeling emotionally exhausted, counselling can offer a safe space to talk.

Because whatever is happening in the world around us, we are still individuals deserving of dignity, compassion and the freedom to be ourselves.

Previous
Previous

What Is Gender Dysphoria? Understanding Gender Identity and Emotional Wellbeing

Next
Next

How do I know if I am transgender?