Why evidence, compassion and the mental health of transgender young people must all be part of the conversation.
By Marianne Oakes, Founder of Evolve Online Counselling
Originally written in response to the publication of the Cass Review in April 2024.
Anyone who is transgender, non-binary or gender-diverse will almost certainly have heard of the Cass Review.
And for many people who are questioning their gender identity, or supporting someone who is, its publication has brought another wave of uncertainty and concern.
The 388-page review, examining NHS gender identity services for children and young people in England, has become the focus of an enormous amount of political, medical and public debate.
But behind those debates are real people.
Young people trying to understand themselves.
Parents desperately trying to support their children.
And transgender adults who remember what it felt like to grow up without the understanding or support they needed.
As a transgender woman and therapeutic counsellor, I cannot separate this conversation from the emotional wellbeing of the people I work with.
Because whatever conclusions are reached about medical treatment, we cannot afford to overlook the human consequences.
My response to the Cass Review
I'll start by putting something out there.
When I first wrote about the Cass Review, I hadn't read the entire report.
Why?
Because as a transgender woman and therapeutic counsellor, I was busy supporting people in my community who were already experiencing significant emotional distress.
Much of my work involves helping transgender and non-binary individuals process experiences of rejection, discrimination, anxiety and feeling invalidated.
I was hearing directly from people who were frightened about what the review might mean for their future.
And I was seeing the emotional impact that the surrounding public debate was having on them.
I recognise that a comprehensive review of healthcare deserves careful consideration, and I would never suggest that medical evidence should be ignored.
But I also believe that the lived experiences of transgender people deserve to be taken seriously.
For me, the immediate concern wasn't simply what was written in the report.
It was how the conclusions would be interpreted, how services might change and what those changes could mean for people already struggling to access support.
We should always be willing to discuss the best care
I have no objection to discussing the best healthcare options for transgender people of any age.
In fact, I welcome those conversations.
We should all want medical treatments to be safe, effective and supported by the strongest possible evidence.
That is in everyone's interests, particularly those of transgender people themselves.
But I believe any conversation about restricting or changing healthcare must also ask an equally important question:
What support will be available instead?
If a treatment is considered insufficiently supported by evidence, we need to understand the limitations of that evidence.
We need to examine potential benefits and risks.
And we need to consider the consequences of delaying or withholding an intervention, alongside the possible consequences of providing it.
That doesn't mean every treatment should automatically be available to everyone.
It means that decisions about care should consider the whole person, including their physical health, emotional wellbeing, individual circumstances and long-term needs.
Puberty blockers and the importance of balanced evidence
One of the most controversial aspects of the Cass Review was its examination of puberty-suppressing medication.
The review raised concerns about the quality and certainty of the available evidence relating to the benefits and risks of puberty blockers for young people experiencing gender dysphoria.
Those concerns deserve proper scientific investigation.
There are legitimate questions about long-term outcomes, including bone health, development, fertility-related considerations and psychological wellbeing.
However, I believe it is equally important to recognise the distress that some young people experience during puberty.
For a young person experiencing significant gender dysphoria, the development of unwanted physical characteristics can be deeply upsetting.
The emotional consequences may extend into relationships, education, confidence and everyday life.
Medical decisions must therefore consider both the uncertainties surrounding treatment and the potential consequences of not providing it.
The absence of strong evidence for a particular benefit does not automatically establish that a treatment is ineffective. Equally, positive individual experiences do not establish that a treatment is safe or effective for everyone.
We need research that is rigorous, transparent and capable of examining these questions without losing sight of the people affected.
What I have seen in my counselling practice
Throughout my work with transgender young people and their families, I have heard many different experiences.
Some young people have described significant emotional relief after accessing puberty-suppressing treatment.
Parents have spoken about improvements they noticed in their child's confidence, social engagement and emotional wellbeing.
Those experiences have stayed with me.
But I also recognise that the experiences of people I meet in counselling cannot establish how effective a treatment is across a wider population.
Individual outcomes differ, and changes in wellbeing may be influenced by several factors, including family support, social acceptance and access to appropriate care.
Nevertheless, these experiences matter.
They deserve to be listened to and investigated rather than dismissed.
For me, good healthcare involves understanding both the scientific evidence and the individual sitting in front of you.
The mental health consequences cannot be ignored
One of my greatest concerns is the emotional impact of the wider debate on transgender young people.
Growing up can be difficult enough without feeling that your identity is constantly being questioned.
For some transgender children and young people, puberty brings additional distress.
For others, the greatest challenges may involve bullying, isolation, family difficulties or fear about the future.
And for some, these experiences can contribute to serious mental health difficulties.
As a counsellor, I have worked with people experiencing anxiety, depression, low self-esteem and, at times, suicidal thoughts.
These are not abstract issues to me.
They are experiences that people bring into the therapy room.
We must take suicide risk seriously without assuming that every transgender young person will experience it, or that any single medical intervention has been proven to prevent suicide.
What matters is that young people experiencing significant distress receive timely, appropriate and compassionate support.
Changing access to medical treatment must never mean abandoning the people who need care.
There is no emotionally neutral option
One of the points I feel most strongly about is the idea that withholding treatment is necessarily a neutral decision.
It isn't always.
Providing medical treatment can involve risks.
But delaying or withholding treatment can also have consequences.
Puberty continues.
Physical changes occur.
Emotional distress may persist or intensify for some individuals.
These realities need to be considered when assessing the overall benefits and harms of different approaches.
I am not arguing that every young person should receive medical treatment.
Nor am I suggesting that the evidence can be set aside because someone is experiencing distress.
I am arguing that the consequences of every available option deserve careful consideration.
That includes the consequences of doing nothing medically while someone continues to experience significant gender dysphoria.
Research, professional disagreement and transgender healthcare
Transgender healthcare is an area in which there are genuine disagreements about how best to interpret the available evidence.
Professional organisations, researchers and healthcare systems have reached different conclusions about particular treatments and the standards of evidence required.
Organisations such as the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) have published guidance supporting individualised gender-affirming healthcare.
Other reviews, including the Cass Review, have raised concerns about the certainty of evidence for some medical interventions in children and adolescents.
These differences should be examined openly.
They should not automatically be treated as proof that one side is acting in bad faith.
I want the research to be as robust as possible.
I want patients and families to have accurate information.
And I want healthcare professionals to be able to discuss uncertainties without fear or political pressure.
But I also want transgender people to feel that their experiences are being heard.
Scientific scrutiny and compassion should not be competing priorities.
They should be working together.
The damage caused by public hostility
Beyond the medical debate, there is another issue that concerns me enormously.
The way transgender people are discussed in public.
Political arguments, media coverage and social media can sometimes make transgender young people feel as though their very existence is controversial.
They may hear themselves described in ways that bear little resemblance to their everyday lives.
They may see adults arguing about their identities without listening to what they have to say.
For young people already struggling with confidence, anxiety or belonging, this can be emotionally exhausting.
People are entitled to disagree about medical policy.
They are entitled to question research and advocate for different approaches to healthcare.
But those disagreements should never become an excuse for hostility towards transgender people.
We can debate healthcare without dehumanising the people who need it.
And we can discuss safeguarding without making transgender young people feel that they are the problem.
Being transgender is part of human diversity
One of the things I have learned through my own life and professional experience is that gender identity is deeply personal.
Not everyone understands why someone is transgender.
And perhaps we will never have a single explanation that captures the full complexity of human gender identity.
But we don't need to understand every aspect of another person's experience to treat them with dignity.
Transgender people have existed across different societies and periods of history.
Our experiences are varied.
Our identities are individual.
And our lives involve far more than medical treatment or political debate.
As a counsellor, I believe that people should have the opportunity to explore their identities in an environment that is safe, respectful and free from pressure.
That includes the freedom to question, reflect and develop their own understanding of themselves.
What does compassionate care actually look like?
For me, compassionate care begins with listening.
It means taking someone's distress seriously without assuming that we already know the answer.
It means providing clear information about the potential benefits, limitations and risks of different options.
It means recognising that young people need appropriate safeguarding and individualised assessment.
And it means ensuring that emotional support remains available, regardless of whether someone pursues medical treatment.
Good care should involve collaboration between patients, families where appropriate, and suitably qualified professionals.
It should allow space for uncertainty.
It should recognise that different individuals may need different forms of support.
Above all, it should remember that the person receiving care is a human being, not a political argument.
Why I believe counselling matters
Counselling cannot resolve every question about medical treatment.
Nor should a counsellor attempt to make medical decisions on behalf of a client.
But counselling can provide something extremely important.
A place where someone feels able to talk openly.
A place where their experiences are taken seriously.
A place where they can explore anxiety, identity, relationships, uncertainty and difficult emotions without being pushed towards a predetermined outcome.
As a person-centred counsellor, my role is to support people in understanding themselves and developing confidence in their own experiences.
I don't believe that transgender young people should be treated as though their identities are inherently invalid.
And I don't believe that questioning your gender should automatically lead to a particular medical pathway.
I believe that people deserve thoughtful, respectful and individualised support.
The Cass Report is not the whole answer
The Cass Review has raised important questions about evidence, healthcare pathways and how services should support children and young people experiencing gender-related distress.
Those questions deserve serious consideration.
But a review of medical evidence cannot, by itself, answer every question about the emotional wellbeing of transgender people.
It cannot replace listening to patients.
It cannot remove the need for compassionate care.
And it cannot make the challenges of growing up transgender disappear.
As a transgender woman, I know what it feels like to carry distress associated with gender identity.
As a counsellor, I hear from people who are trying to navigate those feelings in a world that can sometimes seem determined to debate their lives without understanding them.
I want better research.
I want safe and effective healthcare.
I want young people and their families to have access to appropriate support.
And I want a society where transgender people can explore their identities without fear, hostility or judgement.
Because the answer cannot simply be about what treatments we provide or restrict.
It must also be about how we care for the people whose lives are affected.
At Evolve Online Counselling, I provide specialist online gender-affirming counselling for transgender, non-binary and gender-questioning individuals across the UK, alongside emotional support for parents and families.
Whether you're struggling with gender dysphoria, uncertainty about healthcare, anxiety or the emotional impact of public debate, counselling can offer a confidential space to talk.
Every person deserves evidence-based healthcare, dignity, understanding and compassion.
This article is a personal and professional reflection on the Cass Review, not a clinical assessment of its findings or individual medical advice. Decisions about medical treatment should be discussed with appropriately qualified healthcare professionals.