This will end: Reflections on transgender rights and the Supreme Court ruling

To the average onlooker, the Supreme Court ruling from April 2025 may seem like something that will have little effect on everyday life. At first glance, it can appear distant and technical, with no real impact beyond legal circles. However, the consequences are already being felt in ways that go far beyond the wording of the judgment itself. This is especially striking because even the ruling made clear that it was not intended to materially reduce the rights of transgender people, or words to that effect. Despite that, fear and uncertainty are already shaping how organisations respond.

To me, it feels very similar to Section 28 all over again. That was another law which, in practice, caused harm far beyond its text. It remained in place not because it was especially strong or fair, but because challenging it required money, energy, and determination that many people simply did not have. The result was that institutions became cautious and restrictive, often going further than the law itself required.

We are already seeing the same pattern now. Organisations such as the Women’s Institute and the Girl Guides have reportedly faced pressure and threats of legal action based on interpretations of the Supreme Court judgment. In response, some have moved to exclude trans women and girls. This mirrors the climate created by Section 28, where schools, councils, and other bodies removed anything that might be seen as “promoting” LGBTQ+ identities. Decisions were made out of fear rather than fairness, and exclusion became normalised because few were willing or able to challenge it.

I am not a legal expert. I am simply a trans woman trying to live my life. But I have been around long enough to recognise this pattern, and I know how these moments can unfold. What starts as a narrow legal issue can quickly become a much wider social problem when people and organisations overreact to avoid risk.

This situation will end. The real question is how much damage will be done before it does. How many WI groups and Girl Guide packs will close, as some already have, because they refuse to exclude people? How many organisations will quietly step back from inclusion rather than stand up for what is right? How long will it take before more people begin to say no?

Eventually, the wider public understood the injustice of Section 28. The same will happen here. These moments rarely last forever. But history also shows that progress can come far too slowly, leaving many people hurt in the meantime.

My hope is that it does not take as long this time. I hope enough people care, and that enough people are willing to speak up—in conversations, on doorsteps, and in emails to their MPs. Change only happens when people stop being passive. If the UK is going to be a country we can be proud of, it depends on moments like this: the things we refuse to ignore, and the people we choose to stand beside.

Author: Marianne Oakes diversity and inclusion

Previous
Previous

10 years of writing gender-affirming surgery referral letters: Lessons learned

Next
Next

Thriving through challenge: Finding hope and resilience as a transgender person