Understanding induced lactation, transgender parenthood and the importance of informed choices.
By Marianne Oakes, Founder of Evolve Online Counselling
There has been a great deal of discussion in the media about transgender women breastfeeding their own children.
Apparently, for some people, breastfeeding is a privilege that should only be available to the parent who gives birth.
Yet science and medical practice have developed to the point where some adoptive mothers can induce lactation, and where two mothers in a same-sex relationship may be able to share the experience of breastfeeding their child.
These possibilities have existed for some time.
But when the conversation turns to transgender women, suddenly we see outrage, controversy and headlines questioning whether we should be allowed to participate in something so deeply personal.
As a transgender woman, I find this frustrating.
Why should a transgender mother's wish to nurture and bond with her child be treated so differently from that of any other mother?
Breastfeeding is about more than giving birth
Breastfeeding is often associated with pregnancy and childbirth, but lactation is not exclusively dependent on having given birth.
Induced lactation involves stimulating milk production through methods that may include hormonal treatment, breast stimulation and pumping.
It has been used by some adoptive parents and non-gestational mothers who wish to breastfeed their children.
There are also published medical case reports documenting induced lactation in transgender women.
These developments are important because they demonstrate that our understanding of parenthood, reproduction and infant feeding continues to evolve.
However, induced lactation does not always produce a full milk supply, and research into milk composition and infant outcomes in transgender women remains limited.
Anyone considering induced lactation should seek advice from appropriately qualified healthcare professionals, including specialists in infant feeding and lactation.
The wellbeing and nutritional needs of the baby must always come first.
But surely that is true for every family, regardless of the parents' gender identities?
Why does transgender breastfeeding create such controversy?
What concerns me is the way transgender parenthood is so often presented in the media.
Rather than approaching the subject with curiosity, compassion and an interest in medical evidence, some reporting turns it into another opportunity to question the legitimacy of transgender people's lives.
Suddenly, a deeply personal decision between parents and healthcare professionals becomes a national debate.
And once again, transgender people find themselves being talked about rather than listened to.
I have spent many years working with transgender and gender-diverse people, and I understand the emotional impact that constant public scrutiny can have.
When every aspect of your life becomes a subject for argument, even ordinary family decisions can feel unnecessarily complicated.
Transgender women are women.
Some of us are mothers.
And like other mothers, we want what is best for our children.
That should not be controversial.
Every family deserves informed choices
When anyone is preparing to become a parent, there are important conversations to be had.
How will we care for our child?
How will we share responsibilities?
What support might we need?
And how will we make sure our baby receives the best possible nutritional and emotional start in life?
These questions matter whether a family consists of a single parent, a heterosexual couple, two mothers, two fathers, adoptive parents or a polyamorous parenting arrangement.
There is no single family structure that has a monopoly on love, commitment or good parenting.
Infant feeding decisions should be guided by reliable medical information, the individual circumstances of the family and the nutritional needs of the child.
For some families, breastfeeding may be possible and desirable.
For others, expressed breast milk, donor milk where appropriately available, formula feeding or a combination of feeding methods may be the most suitable choice.
Induced lactation may be an option worth exploring, but it requires individual medical assessment and careful monitoring.
What matters is that parents receive accurate information and compassionate support rather than judgement.
Breastfeeding, bonding and emotional connection
One aspect of this discussion that I feel is often overlooked is the emotional relationship between a parent and child.
Becoming a parent is about much more than biology.
It's about nurturing, protecting, comforting and developing a relationship that will hopefully last a lifetime.
Breastfeeding can be a meaningful bonding experience for some parents.
But it is important to remember that secure attachment does not depend on breastfeeding.
Babies can develop strong, loving and secure relationships with their parents through responsive care, physical closeness, affection and consistent attention, regardless of how they are fed.
For transgender women who wish to explore breastfeeding, the emotional significance of that experience deserves to be understood and respected.
Equally, transgender mothers who cannot or choose not to breastfeed are no less mothers.
Parenthood should never be measured by someone's ability to produce milk.
What makes a parent is not simply how a child is fed, but the love, care and commitment they receive throughout their life.
The mental health impact of questioning transgender families
As a therapeutic counsellor, I see how stigma and discrimination can affect transgender people's emotional wellbeing.
For transgender parents, public hostility can create additional pressures at a time when they may already be navigating the enormous responsibilities of raising a child.
Being constantly questioned about your identity, your family relationships or your ability to parent can contribute to anxiety, self-doubt and feelings of exclusion.
And this is where I believe we need to show greater compassion.
Families should be supported in building loving, stable environments for their children.
They should not be made to feel that their relationships are somehow less legitimate because they don't fit a traditional expectation.
The emotional wellbeing of parents matters too.
When parents feel respected, supported and confident in their roles, that can benefit the wider family.
Diverse families are equally valid
If you're part of a diverse family, whether you're transgender, non-binary, gay, lesbian, bisexual, polyamorous, a single parent or an adoptive parent, your family deserves respect.
You don't need to fit the traditional image of a heterosexual couple with 2.2 children to provide a loving home.
And you certainly shouldn't have to defend your family's existence simply because someone else finds it unfamiliar.
Medical developments may create opportunities for some parents to experience breastfeeding who would previously have thought it impossible.
Those opportunities should be considered responsibly, with appropriate clinical advice and the child's wellbeing at the centre of every decision.
But the wider principle is simple.
Transgender parents deserve the same dignity, respect and access to informed healthcare discussions as every other parent.
We should be celebrating families who want to nurture their children, not turning their lives into another culture-war headline.
Because families come in all shapes and sizes.
And love, commitment and good parenting are not exclusive to any one gender identity or family structure.
Further reading: Marianne Oakes in PinkNews
If you would like to explore this subject further, including my thoughts on transgender women breastfeeding and the research surrounding induced lactation, you can read the article published by PinkNews in August 2023.
Read the PinkNews article about transgender women and breastfeeding
About Marianne Oakes
I'm Marianne Oakes, a transgender woman, therapeutic counsellor and founder of Evolve Online Counselling.
I specialise in supporting transgender, non-binary and gender-questioning people, alongside parents and families navigating identity, relationships and emotional wellbeing.
My person-centred approach provides a confidential, compassionate and non-judgemental space where people can explore their experiences without pressure or expectations.
Find out more about Evolve Online Counselling: