Why exploring your gender identity should never be something to fear
By Marianne Oakes | Evolve Online Counselling
It seemed so innocuous at the time.
I remember going to see my GP to ask for a referral to my local Gender Identity Clinic. He openly admitted that he had never made a referral like this before and explained that he would need to do some research.
I appreciated his honesty.
But during that conversation, he asked me a few questions that, looking back, have stayed with me.
He suggested that I might need a mental health assessment and asked whether I was struggling with my mental health.
I said no.
He then asked whether I was suicidal.
Again, I said no. Quite the opposite.
"I'm here because I want my life to be the best it can be."
What strikes me now is that this was a man who had just admitted he knew very little about the referral process, yet he already appeared to have an idea of what someone like me should be experiencing.
And I wasn't what he expected.
I was calm, assured in my identity and looking forward to making positive changes in my life.
He seemed genuinely confused by this.
I don't blame him for his assumptions. I believe he was trying to help, and I was grateful that he acknowledged his lack of experience.
I was also incredibly nervous during that appointment. I wouldn't have challenged him, even if I had recognised what was happening.
And perhaps, if I'm honest, I had absorbed some of those assumptions myself.
After all, I had grown up surrounded by the same societal messaging about transgender people.
Why do we expect transgender people to be suffering?
For decades, the image of transgender people has been closely associated with psychological distress, confusion and mental illness.
We are often portrayed as people living on the edge of despair, struggling to function or desperately unhappy with our lives.
Of course, some transgender people do experience profound emotional distress.
I know this because, over the years, I have worked with thousands of transgender people in my therapy room.
I have sat with people who have experienced bullying, rejection, humiliation and discrimination. People whose lives have been profoundly affected by the attitudes of others, and people who have struggled for years to understand and accept themselves.
But equally, I have worked with people who are confident, emotionally grounded and completely assured in their gender identity.
People who have successful careers, loving relationships, families and fulfilling lives.
People who are not in crisis.
People who simply want to understand themselves better or make changes that allow them to live more authentically.
And that is something I think we need to talk about more.
Being transgender is not a mental illness, and experiencing gender incongruence does not automatically mean someone is psychologically unwell.
When healthcare expects distress
My experience at the Gender Identity Clinic reinforced something I had first encountered in my GP's surgery.
I often felt that the questions were weighted towards finding distress, desperation and psychological suffering.
At times, it almost seemed as though the answers expected of me were the ones I couldn't honestly give.
That I was desperate. That I couldn't function. That I had contemplated ending my life.
But that wasn't my experience.
I wasn't seeking healthcare because my life was falling apart.
I was seeking healthcare because I wanted my life to be better.
There is an important difference.
And I wonder how many other transgender people have felt that they needed to demonstrate suffering to have their experiences taken seriously.
Because when we repeatedly associate gender incongruence with psychological distress, we risk overlooking the many people who are exploring their gender identity from a place of curiosity, confidence or self-awareness.
We also risk sending a message to those who are only beginning to question their gender.
That there must be something wrong with them.
And there isn't.
Exploring your gender identity doesn't have to be frightening
One of the things I have learned through my work as a counsellor is that people come to understand their gender identity in very different ways.
For some, there has always been a clear sense of who they are.
For others, that understanding develops gradually, sometimes over many years.
Some people begin questioning their gender identity in childhood or adolescence. Others don't begin exploring these feelings until much later in life.
And some people aren't entirely sure what their feelings mean.
All of these experiences deserve understanding and respect.
If you are beginning to question your gender identity, you may find yourself asking questions you have never previously allowed yourself to consider.
What does my gender mean to me?
Why have I always felt slightly different?
Am I transgender, non-binary, or simply someone who doesn't fit comfortably within society's expectations of gender?
What would it mean to explore these feelings further?
These questions can feel enormous, particularly when we live in a society that so often presents gender diversity as something controversial or frightening.
But questioning your gender identity is not something you need to fear.
It is an opportunity to understand yourself.
And understanding yourself doesn't require you to arrive at a particular conclusion.
You don't have to decide whether you are transgender.
You don't have to change your name, your appearance or the way you live.
You don't have to pursue medical treatment.
And you certainly don't have to prove that you are suffering.
You can simply give yourself permission to explore.
The importance of having space to explore
In my counselling work, I have met many people who have spent years trying to push away their feelings about gender.
Sometimes because they were frightened of what those feelings might mean.
Sometimes because they worried about their relationships, their families or how other people might react.
And sometimes because they simply didn't have anyone they felt safe enough to talk to.
For some, the process of exploring their gender identity brings clarity and reassurance.
For others, it raises more questions.
And that's okay.
Counselling can provide a space where those questions can be explored without judgement, pressure or expectation.
Not because there is something wrong with you.
Not because your gender identity needs to be explained away or corrected.
But because sometimes having someone alongside you, someone who will listen, understand and help you explore your thoughts and feelings, can make that journey less daunting.
Good gender-affirming counselling isn't about telling someone who they are. It is about supporting them in discovering what their identity means to them.
And sometimes that exploration leads to transition. Sometimes it doesn't.
Neither outcome should be predetermined by the counsellor.
What matters is that the person has the freedom to explore their own experience and make decisions that feel right for them.
We are not what you expect us to be
I want to return to something that has troubled me for many years.
The way transgender people are represented in society.
The media has frequently portrayed us as mentally unstable, confused, fetishists or sexual predators.
Hollywood has presented transgender characters as figures of ridicule, deception or even violence.
These portrayals attract attention. They entertain. They shock. They sell.
But they also shape expectations.
And when those expectations are repeated often enough, people can begin to mistake fictional stereotypes for reality.
Yet transgender people are not a monolith.
We are part of society in all its diversity.
We are parents, grandparents, partners, professionals, tradespeople, neighbours and friends.
Some of us are confident. Some are shy. Some are successful. Some struggle.
Some have experienced profound trauma, while others have lived relatively ordinary lives.
Just like everyone else.
Our gender identity doesn't determine our mental health, our personalities or our ability to live fulfilling lives.
And perhaps this explains why so many people believe they have never met a transgender person.
Not because we are all hiding.
Not because we necessarily blend in.
But because we are not what they have been taught to expect.
They have been looking for the stereotype rather than seeing the person.
Just as my GP did all those years ago.
You don't have to be struggling to deserve support
When I think back to that appointment, I remember how nervous I was.
But I also remember how certain I felt about why I was there.
I wasn't asking someone to fix me.
I wasn't looking for someone to tell me who I was.
I simply wanted the opportunity to live my life in a way that felt right for me.
And that is what I would want anyone beginning to explore their gender identity to understand.
You don't have to be in crisis to seek support.
You don't have to have all the answers.
You don't even have to know where your exploration might lead.
Sometimes the most important thing you can do is allow yourself the space to ask questions, to be curious and to understand yourself without fear.
Because exploring who you are should never be something you have to apologise for.
And perhaps, rather than asking why someone wants to explore their gender identity, we should be asking how we can help them feel safe enough to do so.
Exploring your gender identity with Evolve Online Counselling
At Evolve Online Counselling, we understand that exploring gender identity is a deeply personal experience.
Whether you are beginning to question your gender, have been exploring your feelings for years, or simply want a safe space to talk, our online gender-affirming counselling offers an opportunity to explore at your own pace.
There is no expectation that you will arrive at a particular identity or make any specific changes to your life.
Our role is to listen, support and help you develop a greater understanding of yourself.
You don't have to be struggling to benefit from counselling. Sometimes wanting to understand yourself better is reason enough.
Evolve Online Counselling provides specialist online gender-affirming counselling across the UK.