By Marianne Oakes | Transgender woman, therapeutic counsellor and gender specialist
There are moments when I watch the news and wonder how, as a society, we have become so skilled at discussing women's safety while repeatedly failing to confront the violence that threatens it.
The Russell Brand case has brought questions about sexual violence, power, celebrity and accountability back into the national conversation.
On 9 November 2026, Russell Brand was sentenced to 10 years and six months in prison following his conviction for one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault.
And once again, we are asking familiar questions.
How could this happen? Who knew? Why weren't concerns taken seriously? Why did it take so long for people to be heard?
But there is another question I believe we desperately need to ask.
Why have we spent so much of the last decade being encouraged to fear transgender women while the reality of male violence against women has remained so devastatingly clear?
I ask this not simply as a therapeutic counsellor and gender specialist, but as a transgender woman who has watched her identity become a political battleground.
And frankly, I am exhausted by it.
Violence Against Women: Are We Focusing on the Wrong Threat?
Violence against women and girls is one of the most serious issues facing our society.
Domestic abuse, sexual assault, coercive control, harassment and violence by intimate partners are not hypothetical dangers. They are real experiences that affect countless women and families.
Yet when I look at the public debate surrounding women's safety, I see an extraordinary amount of political and media attention devoted to transgender women.
Our access to toilets. Our participation in sport. Our healthcare. Our right to be recognised and respected.
Again and again, transgender women are presented as though our very existence represents a threat.
And I find myself asking:
Where is this same relentless determination when it comes to challenging male violence, misogyny and the institutions that have failed survivors?
I am not suggesting that women's concerns about privacy, dignity or safety should be dismissed. Those concerns deserve thoughtful discussion.
But so does the safety and dignity of transgender women.
And I refuse to accept that protecting one group of women must mean treating another group as inherently dangerous.
Transgender Women and the Media: A Decade of Fear and Division
Over the past decade, transgender people have become the subject of extraordinary political and media scrutiny.
Our identities have been debated in Parliament, dissected across newspaper headlines and discussed on television by people who often have little understanding of our lived experiences.
For transgender women, this has frequently meant being portrayed through a lens of suspicion.
We are discussed as risks to be managed, problems to be solved or threats to be contained.
Rarely are we simply allowed to be women living ordinary lives.
I remember when being transgender did not seem to dominate the national conversation in quite the same way.
People might not always have understood us, but our existence was not constantly presented as a source of public controversy.
Today, it can feel as though every aspect of our lives is open to debate.
And I cannot help wondering what might have been achieved if even a fraction of that political energy and media attention had been directed towards investigating institutional failures to protect women from abuse.
How many survivors might have been heard sooner?
How many complaints might have been taken more seriously?
How many organisations might have been forced to confront cultures that allowed harassment and abuse to continue?
We cannot know the answers.
But surely these are questions worth asking.
Women's Rights, Trans Rights and the Politics of Fear
Organisations such as Sex Matters and For Women Scotland, alongside prominent campaigners including J.K. Rowling, have played influential roles in debates about sex, gender and women's rights.
They are entitled to express their views and campaign for the changes they believe are necessary.
Just as I am entitled to challenge those arguments and question their consequences.
My concern is not that every person who questions transgender inclusion is indifferent to male violence. That would be an unfair assumption.
My concern is about the priorities of our public conversation.
When transgender inclusion becomes a dominant subject in debates about women's safety, we risk losing sight of other serious and extensively documented threats.
I want to know why discussions about protecting women so often become arguments about whether women like me should be allowed to participate in everyday life.
Why is my presence in a changing room considered worthy of endless national debate, while failures to respond to sexual harassment, domestic abuse and institutional misconduct can struggle to sustain the same attention?
Women's safety should never become a competition between different groups of women.
We should be demanding meaningful protections, better services, effective safeguarding and genuine accountability.
Not encouraging women to view one another with suspicion.
Male Violence, Institutional Failure and the Abuse of Power
One of the most troubling aspects of high-profile sexual abuse cases is how often questions arise about the environments in which alleged misconduct occurred.
Did people feel able to raise concerns?
Were complaints investigated appropriately?
Did professional influence, reputation or financial interests affect how concerns were handled?
Were people afraid that speaking out would damage their careers or relationships?
These questions matter because safeguarding is about more than written policies.
An organisation can have extensive safeguarding procedures and still create a culture in which people are frightened to speak.
A workplace can publicly champion equality while privately tolerating inappropriate behaviour.
An institution can claim to support survivors while failing to challenge the power structures that silence them.
Safeguarding without accountability is not enough.
If we are serious about protecting women, we must be prepared to confront the misuse of power wherever it occurs.
That means challenging harmful attitudes, taking complaints seriously and ensuring that fame, wealth or professional status do not place anyone beyond scrutiny.
Have Transgender Women Become a Convenient Distraction?
This is perhaps the most uncomfortable question I find myself asking.
Have transgender women become a convenient distraction from the more difficult conversations society needs to have?
I am not suggesting that there is some coordinated conspiracy to blame transgender people for violence committed by men.
But I do believe that transgender women have become an easy target in an increasingly polarised political environment.
We are a relatively small minority, and many people have limited personal experience of knowing someone who is transgender.
That makes it easier for misinformation, stereotypes and fear to shape public attitudes.
It is easier to create outrage around a hypothetical situation involving a transgender woman than to investigate the complicated systems that allow abuse to go unchallenged.
It is easier to debate someone's identity than to examine the uncomfortable realities of institutional power, misogyny and violence.
And it is easier to divide women than to bring them together around the changes that could genuinely improve safety.
Transgender women should not be made scapegoats for society's failure to confront male violence.
Transgender Women's Safety Matters Too
There is something deeply painful about hearing women's safety discussed as though transgender women are somehow excluded from that conversation.
As though our vulnerability does not matter.
As though we cannot experience domestic abuse, sexual violence, harassment or intimidation.
As though our safety is less deserving of protection.
Throughout my professional life as a therapeutic counsellor and gender specialist, I have listened to transgender people describe the emotional impact of rejection, discrimination, hostility and the constant questioning of their identities.
I have witnessed how prolonged exposure to negative messages can affect someone's confidence, relationships, emotional wellbeing and sense of belonging.
And as a transgender woman myself, I understand the exhaustion that can come from feeling that you must continually justify your existence.
This is not simply a political disagreement played out in newspapers.
These debates affect real people.
People with families, relationships, careers, friendships and ordinary hopes for their futures.
People who want to feel safe walking down the street, accessing healthcare, going to work and participating in society.
I am one of those people.
My safety matters. My dignity matters. And my identity should not make me a legitimate target for hostility.
Protecting All Women Should Be Our Shared Priority
I want women to be safe.
I want girls to grow up in a society where sexual harassment and violence are challenged rather than normalised.
I want survivors of abuse to be listened to, supported and treated with dignity.
I want organisations to take safeguarding seriously, rather than viewing it as an administrative obligation.
I want those who abuse positions of power to be held accountable.
And I want transgender women to be able to live without constantly being portrayed as a danger to others.
None of these aspirations should be incompatible.
We can recognise that women have different experiences, needs and concerns without allowing those differences to become a justification for hostility.
We can have difficult conversations about rights, privacy and safeguarding without dehumanising transgender people.
And we can acknowledge the complexity of these issues while refusing to lose sight of the violence and abuse that demand urgent attention.
Protecting women should mean protecting women from violence, not turning women against one another.
The Emotional Impact of Anti-Transgender Hostility
As a counsellor, I am particularly concerned about the psychological impact of prolonged public hostility towards transgender people.
When your identity is repeatedly questioned, criticised or portrayed negatively, it can affect how safe you feel in the world.
For some people, this may contribute to anxiety, isolation, reduced self-esteem or a reluctance to seek support.
For others, it can reinforce feelings of shame or the belief that they must hide important parts of themselves to be accepted.
These experiences do not happen in isolation.
They exist alongside everyday pressures involving relationships, employment, family life and personal wellbeing.
This is why compassionate, informed and affirming therapeutic support can be so important.
At Evolve Online Counselling, we recognise that gender identity, emotional wellbeing and personal safety are deeply connected to how people experience the world around them.
Everyone deserves a space where they can explore their experiences without judgement, pressure or the expectation that they must defend who they are.
The Questions We Should Be Asking About Women's Safety
The next time another high-profile case involving allegations of sexual misconduct dominates the headlines, I hope we ask more meaningful questions.
Not simply how something could have happened, but what systems allowed concerns to go unanswered.
Not simply whether safeguarding policies existed, but whether people felt safe enough to use them.
Not simply whether an individual held power, but how that power was exercised and challenged.
And perhaps, alongside those questions, we should ask ourselves something else.
Has our national obsession with debating transgender people's lives distracted us from the work required to make society safer for everyone?
I do not expect everyone reading this article to agree with me.
I understand that debates about sex, gender and women's rights involve deeply held beliefs and genuine disagreements.
But disagreement should not prevent us from recognising our shared humanity.
Nor should it stop us from challenging violence, supporting survivors and demanding accountability.
I Refuse to Be Your Scapegoat
I am a transgender woman.
I am also a daughter, a partner, a friend, a counsellor and someone who has spent years supporting people through some of the most difficult experiences of their lives.
I am not a political argument.
I am not a safeguarding crisis.
And I am certainly not responsible for violence committed by men.
I am a woman who wants to live her life with the same dignity, freedom and safety that every other woman deserves.
I want a society where survivors are heard, where abuse is challenged and where powerful people cannot rely on their influence to avoid scrutiny.
And I want us to stop pretending that making life harder for transgender women will somehow solve the problem of violence against women.
Because it won't.
The existence of transgender women is not the cause of male violence, misogyny or institutional abuse.
Those problems require serious, sustained action.
They require courage, accountability and a willingness to challenge the structures that allow harm to continue.
So the next time someone tells you that women need protecting from people like me, I ask you to consider who is actually committing violence, whose voices are being overlooked and whether our attention is being directed towards meaningful solutions.
Because women who have experienced abuse deserve more than another round of public outrage.
They deserve to be heard.
They deserve justice.
And they deserve change.
I am a woman. I deserve to be safe. And I refuse to be made the scapegoat for violence I did not commit.
Marianne Oakes
Transgender woman, therapeutic counsellor and gender specialist
About Evolve Online Counselling
Evolve Online Counselling provides online therapeutic support, including support relating to gender identity, emotional wellbeing and personal experiences of discrimination.
If you are struggling with the emotional impact of hostility, identity-related stress or difficult life experiences, counselling can offer a confidential, compassionate space to explore what you are going through.
Explore our counselling services to find out more about the support available.