A personal reflection on being trans, belonging and hope
By Marianne Oakes | Transgender woman, therapeutic counsellor and gender specialist
There are times, as a therapeutic counsellor, when I find myself being more contained in expressing my own feelings about subjects that affect me personally and affect my community.
It is, perhaps, a little ironic. Counselling is built around authenticity, yet counsellors are human too. We have our own experiences, emotions, frustrations and hopes. We simply have to be thoughtful about how and when we bring those into the spaces in which we work.
Recently, I have found myself reflecting on the current discussion around trans rights, the guidance issued by the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC), and the wider debate about where transgender, non-binary and gender-diverse people belong and how we are expected to navigate everyday life.
And, for once, I don't particularly want to be contained.
I have read the guidance
I have taken the time to read the advice, understand my rights and try to make sense of what it might mean in practical terms. I have passed information on to others, offered encouragement and tried, where possible, to remain measured and calm.
But eventually I found myself asking a fairly simple question:
What am I supposed to do with all this information?
The answer, for me, is that I don't want to spend my life living inside it.
I don't want to feel that I need a working knowledge of legislation and guidance simply to go about ordinary activities. I don't want to wonder whether I am legally permitted to use a toilet, participate in a community activity, play badminton or turn up for a Parkrun.
These are ordinary things.
They are the sorts of things human beings do without having to first establish whether their existence is sufficiently complicated to require legal clarification.
This isn't just about me
I am conscious that my own experience is not everyone's experience.
I am an unapologetic trans woman, but I also recognise that I am fortunate in some respects. I have found ways of developing confidence in who I am, and I have people around me who accept me for who I am.
That doesn't mean I am unaware of the impact that uncertainty, hostility and exclusion can have on other people.
Transgender people, non-binary people and those who are gender diverse can all experience the world differently, and none of us has exactly the same story.
For some, this isn't an interesting legal debate.
It is about whether they feel safe.
It is about whether they feel welcome.
It is about whether they can go to work, access services, participate in their communities or simply live their lives without constantly having to assess the possibility of being challenged, questioned or excluded.
That matters.
And perhaps that is why I have wanted to understand the guidance in the first place. Not because I want to spend my life arguing about legislation, but because knowledge can sometimes be useful when supporting somebody else who is struggling.
I don't want to live defensively
There is a danger, when we are repeatedly told that our rights, identity or place in society are uncertain, that we begin to live defensively.
We check.
We question.
We anticipate.
We prepare ourselves for confrontation before it has even happened.
Over time, that can become exhausting.
As a counsellor, I know how important it can be to understand the difference between being appropriately aware of our environment and living in a constant state of emotional preparation for something to go wrong.
I don't want either for myself or for the people I support.
I want trans, non-binary and gender-diverse people to be able to live ordinary lives.
Not extraordinary lives.
Not lives that require constant courage.
Just ordinary ones.
What happens to us matters. It doesn't have to define us.
Perhaps this is where my thoughts about counselling come into the picture.
One of the things I value most about therapeutic work is the possibility of helping someone recognise that what has happened to them is not the same thing as who they are.
That doesn't mean pretending difficult experiences haven't happened.
It doesn't mean minimising discrimination, prejudice, trauma or hurt.
And it certainly doesn't mean telling somebody to simply “move on”.
It means finding, sometimes very gradually, a sense that we still have some agency over our own lives.
We can acknowledge what has happened without allowing it to become the only story we tell about ourselves.
We can be angry without becoming consumed by anger.
We can be frightened without allowing fear to make every decision for us.
We can recognise injustice without believing that we are powerless.
And perhaps most importantly, we can experience rejection without concluding that we are somehow less worthy because somebody else rejected us.
That isn't about pretending to be strong.
It is about remembering that we are more than the things that happen to us.
Knowing my worth doesn't mean I have all the answers
I've always tried to live by a fairly simple principle: if I am somewhere I am genuinely not welcome, I don't have to stay.
That isn't intended as advice to anyone else, and it certainly isn't a suggestion that people should simply walk away from discrimination.
Sometimes leaving is a choice.
Sometimes it isn't.
Sometimes people have no realistic alternative.
My point is simply that I don't believe my worth is determined by whether another person, organisation or service chooses to recognise it.
And I don't need to be permanently angry to know that.
I can be disappointed.
I can be frustrated.
I can disagree.
I can walk away when I need to.
And I can still hope that things will change.
A little humour helps
If I am honest, I also find some of this rather absurd.
I am not exactly somebody whose life revolves around competitive sport. I am probably about as likely to become a serious athlete as I am to end up having dinner with Tom Cruise.
But the fact that something doesn't personally affect me doesn't mean I shouldn't care about people for whom it does.
That, for me, is one of the more important aspects of community.
We don't all have to experience the same things to care about their impact on one another.
As a counsellor, I know uncertainty can take a toll
One of the things I see repeatedly in therapeutic work is how uncertainty can affect our sense of safety and wellbeing.
When something fundamental about our lives feels unsettled, it can occupy an enormous amount of mental and emotional space.
For trans, non-binary and gender-diverse people, that uncertainty can be compounded by public debate, political arguments, media coverage and changing interpretations of rights and protections.
It can leave people feeling as though their lives are being discussed as an abstract issue rather than experienced as real, everyday lives.
That can be painful.
And it is one reason I think conversations about gender identity and trans rights need to retain some humanity.
Behind every argument about policy, guidance or legislation are people trying to get on with their lives.
I don't want this to be a manifesto
This isn't intended to be a legal analysis, nor is it advice about how anybody should respond to the current situation.
It is simply a personal reflection.
I have spent a lot of time being measured, professional and contained in my responses to things that affect me deeply.
Sometimes that is appropriate.
Sometimes, however, I think authenticity means acknowledging that something has affected you.
This has.
I am frustrated.
I am disappointed.
I am tired of the suggestion that trans people, non-binary people and gender-diverse people should somehow become experts in the rules governing their own existence before they can feel secure within their communities.
But I am not without hope.
I am not a victim of this moment
I don't mean that in the sense that nothing can hurt me.
Things can hurt us.
People can hurt us.
Systems can hurt us.
Discrimination can have very real consequences.
But I don't want those things to become my identity.
I don't want them to become the whole story.
There is a difference between acknowledging that something has happened to us and believing that it has the power to define everything that happens next.
For me, that distinction matters enormously.
Perhaps this is one of the places where counselling can