Trans voices: Why we need to take back the conversation

By Marianne Oakes

When the Debate Became Personal

When it all kicked off around 2017—with Gender Critics and TERFs repeatedly asking politicians and trans people “what is a woman?”—I tried to enter the discussion with good intentions. Very quickly, though, I realised I was just becoming angry. Every trap they set, I tried to respond to in good faith.

Looking back, there was never any good faith on their side—no reasoning, and certainly no amount of evidence that was ever going to assuage their hate. The frustration was bubbling up inside me. They had got into my head, and I hated that I had let it happen.

Recognising the Pattern

Nowadays, for me personally, I’ve accepted that their goal is the total eradication of trans women and, by default, trans men (though trans men have largely been ignored by this hateful mob, they suffer the same fate). It’s a form of reverse misogyny, if there is such a thing—designed to further invalidate all trans people.

They never had evidence or reason, just insults, barbed rhetoric, and landmine-style traps that, like me, many of us walked straight into. The reality is that I now only look to make them say what we already know about their aims. Some, like Helen Joyce, come close but keep their language soft enough to avoid openly talking about killing trans people. Get them to own their views—that is, the “final solution” they imagine for trans people.

Taking Control of the Conversation

You can’t win an argument with someone this far down the rabbit hole. All we can do is keep pushing our voices—sadly without malice, though many of us have it in bucketloads and deservedly so.

At the moment, the trans voices I hear are still having to politely explain why TERFs’ arguments are wrong. I want to hear trans voices setting the agenda and defining the rhetoric. The media won’t let us, but we can accept invitations and use those few minutes to say what we want to say—not what producers direct us to say.

I personally go off topic, throw a curveball—and, unsurprisingly, I don’t get invited back. But I’m not after glory. Just being polite and smiling while making the point I wanted to make.

Why We Need a Different Strategy

This is where I’m at. I don’t expect we’re all in the same place, but I’d love to see a coherent plan. How do we make the most of our media time, no matter how little they give us? How do we stop talking their talk and start talking our talk?

Let’s fall out about it—it doesn’t matter. Over the last ten years, we’ve slipped so far backwards that we have to try a different strategy—if we ever even had a strategy.

Previous
Previous

Trans joy, gender dysphoria and finding support: Counselling for trans and non-binary people

Next
Next

When Care Turns Harmful: The Misuse of Electroconvulsive Therapy