When Care Turns Harmful: The Misuse of Electroconvulsive Therapy

The history of conversion practices, the lasting harm of stigma and why transgender people need understanding rather than attempts to change who they are.

By Marianne Oakes, Founder of Evolve Online Counselling

Yesterday, I watched an interview with a transgender woman who spoke about undergoing electroconvulsive therapy when she was still a teenager.

Sadly, it was a story I had heard before.

Over the years, I've listened to similar experiences from transgender women of my generation, particularly those who were brave enough to come out when they were children.

When I first began interacting with what we then called the trans scene, rather than the transgender community, we would often share stories about our journeys towards living openly as women.

Some were stories of happiness, discovery and liberation.

Others were much harder to hear.

They were stories about rejection, shame, medical mistreatment and attempts to make people stop being who they were.

And some of those experiences have stayed with me for decades.

When treatment was used to enforce conformity

For those unfamiliar with electroconvulsive therapy, or ECT, it is a medical treatment in which a controlled electrical stimulus is used to induce a brief seizure.

Modern ECT is administered under general anaesthesia and can be an effective treatment for certain severe mental health conditions, particularly some forms of severe depression.

But that is not the history I want to talk about.

I want to talk about the historical misuse of psychiatric treatments and aversive techniques in attempts to change people's sexual orientation or gender expression.

During parts of the twentieth century, homosexuality and gender nonconformity were often treated as psychiatric problems.

Some people were subjected to aversion therapies involving electric shocks, while others experienced coercive psychiatric interventions.

It is important to distinguish these practices from modern therapeutic ECT, because they were not always the same procedure.

But the underlying belief behind these attempts was deeply damaging.

That being gay or transgender was something that needed to be corrected.

Imagine being a young person, already frightened about expressing who you are, and being told by medical professionals that your identity is a condition requiring treatment.

Imagine the power imbalance.

The fear.

And the emotional consequences of being made to believe that something fundamental about you was wrong.

For some survivors, those experiences caused lasting psychological harm.

A generation taught that difference was illness

Throughout much of the twentieth century, attitudes towards lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people were shaped by medical classifications, religious beliefs and social expectations.

Homosexuality was historically classified as a mental disorder in major psychiatric diagnostic systems.

Gender-related diagnoses also remained within psychiatric classifications for many years.

In 2019, the World Health Organization adopted the eleventh revision of the International Classification of Diseases, ICD-11, which moved gender incongruence out of the chapter on mental and behavioural disorders. ICD-11 came into effect internationally in 2022.

That was an important development.

It reflected the recognition that being transgender is not, in itself, a mental illness.

Yet the legacy of earlier attitudes remains.

I grew up in a generation where medical authority was rarely questioned.

If a doctor said something was wrong with you, people often accepted it.

If society told you that your identity was unacceptable, there were very few places where you could challenge that message.

And if you were gay or transgender, the pressure to conform could be enormous.

You cannot cure something that isn't an illness

The idea that someone's sexual orientation or gender identity can be deliberately changed through psychological or medical intervention has a long and troubling history.

These approaches are commonly described as conversion practices.

There is no credible evidence that conversion practices can reliably change a person's sexual orientation or gender identity, and major professional bodies have raised serious concerns about the harm they can cause.

Yet for generations, people were encouraged, pressured or forced to deny who they were.

Some learned to say what professionals or family members wanted to hear.

Some withdrew from the world.

Others spent years hiding their identities.

From conversations I've had with transgender people over the past thirty years, I know that some survivors of these experiences eventually told those treating them that they had changed.

But that did not necessarily mean they had.

Sometimes, it meant they wanted the treatment to stop.

Sometimes, it meant they wanted to be safe.

And sometimes, it meant that pretending to conform felt like the only way to survive.

You cannot fix something that was never broken.

The damage doesn't disappear when treatment ends

One of the things I have learned through my counselling work is that stigma can leave emotional wounds that last for years.

People may carry feelings of shame, fear and self-doubt long after the circumstances that created those feelings have changed.

They may struggle with relationships.

They may find it difficult to trust professionals.

They may question their own worth.

And they may feel that they must constantly prove that their identity is legitimate.

As a transgender woman, I understand something of the emotional cost of growing up in a world that doesn't always recognise you.

As a therapeutic counsellor, I hear how those experiences continue to affect people.

Counselling cannot erase the past.

But it can provide a space where someone begins to understand the impact of what happened to them, reconnect with their sense of self and develop greater confidence in who they are.

Have we really learned from the past?

We are now well into the twenty-first century.

And yet, transgender people's identities remain the subject of intense political and public debate.

In the UK and elsewhere, discussions about transgender healthcare frequently become polarised.

There are legitimate questions about the evidence supporting particular medical interventions, especially when considering treatment for children and young people.

Those questions deserve careful scientific examination.

But I worry when the conversation moves away from understanding people's needs and towards treating transgender identity itself as the problem.

We should be able to discuss medical evidence without questioning someone's dignity.

We should be able to consider safeguarding without making transgender young people feel that they are inherently damaged.

And we should be able to disagree about healthcare policy without returning to the attitudes that caused so much suffering in previous generations.

Puberty blockers and the consequences of restricting care

One of my concerns about recent changes to transgender healthcare in the UK has been the restrictions placed on puberty-suppressing medication for young people experiencing gender dysphoria.

I believe it is essential to consider the emotional consequences of these decisions alongside the questions about medical evidence and long-term safety.

The restrictions have been introduced in response to concerns about the evidence for benefits and risks. They are not, in themselves, proof of an intention to change someone's gender identity.

However, I am deeply concerned about what happens when young people experiencing significant distress are left without timely, appropriate alternatives.

For some young people, puberty can be an extremely difficult experience.

Physical changes may intensify gender dysphoria.

Anxiety may increase.

And families may feel uncertain about where to turn.

We need robust evidence about the benefits and risks of treatment.

But we also need to understand the consequences of withholding or delaying care.

Not providing a medical intervention does not remove the responsibility to support the person who needs help.

What I have seen in my counselling work

For more than a decade, I have worked with transgender and gender-diverse people of different ages.

I've supported individuals who were questioning their identities, people beginning their transitions and others who had been living openly for many years.

I have seen the relief that some people experience when they begin to feel comfortable with their bodies and identities.

I've listened to people describe improvements in confidence, relationships and emotional wellbeing.

And I've witnessed how meaningful it can be when someone finally feels recognised and accepted.

In my own professional experience, I have encountered very few people who have expressed regret about transitioning.

But I recognise that my clinical experience represents the people I have worked with, not every transgender person's experience.

It cannot establish population-wide rates of regret or determine the effectiveness of a particular medical intervention.

People's circumstances differ, and some individuals do experience uncertainty, changes in their understanding of identity or dissatisfaction with aspects of treatment.

Those experiences also deserve respectful support.

What my work has reinforced is the importance of listening to individuals rather than making assumptions about them.

The difference between support and trying to change someone

I believe there is a fundamental difference between helping someone explore their identity and attempting to change it.

Gender-affirming counselling should never mean telling someone what their gender identity must be.

It should not pressure someone towards medical transition.

Nor should it pressure them away from it.

As a person-centred counsellor, my role is to provide a safe, confidential and non-judgemental environment where people can explore their feelings and experiences.

That may include questions about identity, relationships, gender dysphoria, anxiety or uncertainty about the future.

The person sitting in front of me is the expert in their own lived experience.

My responsibility is to support their self-understanding, emotional wellbeing and ability to make informed choices.

That is very different from entering a therapeutic relationship with the intention of making someone become a different person.

A message to parents and families

If you are the parent of a transgender child, or someone in your family has recently come out as transgender or non-binary, I want to offer some reassurance.

You do not need to have every answer immediately.

You may have questions.

You may feel uncertain about what the future will look like.

And you may need time to understand experiences that are unfamiliar to you.

That doesn't make you a bad parent or family member.

What matters is how you respond.

Listen to your loved one.

Take their feelings seriously.

Respect their identity and allow space for open conversation.

Seek accurate information and appropriate professional guidance where needed.

And recognise that your own worries should not become a burden that your child or family member is expected to carry alone.

Sometimes, parents benefit from having their own therapeutic space to explore their feelings.

Supporting someone you love can involve learning, reflection and adapting to change.

But the starting point should always be compassion.

Your loved one's gender identity is not something that needs to be cured.

They deserve understanding, respect and support.

Gender-affirming care is about the whole person

When people talk about gender-affirming care, the conversation often focuses almost entirely on medication or surgery.

But supporting transgender people involves much more than medical intervention.

It can involve counselling, family support, social connection, education, emotional wellbeing and helping people navigate difficult experiences.

For some individuals, medical treatment is an important part of their lives.

For others, it isn't.

And for many, their needs change as they develop a greater understanding of themselves.

What matters is that support is individualised, respectful and informed.

No one should be forced towards a particular outcome.

And no one should be made to feel that their identity is inherently wrong.

We must not repeat the mistakes of the past

When I think about the woman whose interview prompted me to write this article, I think about the courage it must have taken to speak publicly about her experiences.

I think about the transgender women of my generation who carried similar stories.

And I think about those who never felt able to tell anyone what happened to them.

Their experiences should remind us why ethical, compassionate healthcare matters.

Medical knowledge changes.

Research develops.

And society learns, sometimes painfully, from the mistakes it has made.

But one principle should remain constant.

Healthcare must never be used to punish someone for who they are.

We can improve evidence.

We can strengthen safeguarding.

We can discuss different treatment approaches.

And we can support people who are questioning their identities without deciding those identities for them.

What we must never do is return to the belief that being transgender, gay or gender-diverse is something that needs to be corrected.

Because the harm caused by stigma is real.

And the answer to that harm is not more shame, punishment or rejection.

It is understanding.

It is compassion.

It is appropriate, evidence-informed care.

And it is recognising that every person deserves the opportunity to live with dignity.

You cannot fix something that was never broken.

About Marianne Oakes

I am Marianne Oakes, a transgender woman, therapeutic counsellor and founder of Evolve Online Counselling.

I also work as Lead Counsellor at Anne Health.

My work focuses on supporting transgender, non-binary and gender-questioning individuals, alongside parents and families navigating gender identity, emotional wellbeing and relationships.

Through my counselling work and podcast conversations, I aim to create opportunities for transgender people and their families to share their experiences, challenges and moments of joy.

If you would like to learn more about the support available, you can visit:

Evolve Online Counselling
https://evolveonlinecounselling.co.uk/

Anne Health
https://anne.health/

Podcast: Trans Voices and Gender-Affirming Care
https://evolveonlinecounselling.co.uk/podcast

Thank you for taking the time to read my thoughts.

And if this article resonates with you, please consider sharing it.

Marianne x

Previous
Previous

Trans voices: Why we need to take back the conversation

Next
Next

Understanding Gender Dysphoria: A Guide to Support and Resources